Customer Reviews

Our Customers Love Us

Read what some of our customers have to say about McColly.

Highly Recommend

My wife and I could not have been more happy with our experience selling our home through McColly Real Estate with Edie Corthran as our realtor. From our very first meeting with Edie we were very comfortable. Edie definitely has the right experience necessary to help get you through the process. It was also obvious to us that McColly offers clients and their realty team the best resources to make sure that everything goes seamlessly. If you are buying or selling a home we highly recommend both McColly Real Estate and Edie Corthran!!

Dan Redden, Nov 2016

...Customer Reviews

Left an everlasting impression

My husband and I could not have had a better experience with your company and your realtor Kristin Nagle McCoy! She was thorough, honest with her feedback and I took in and listen to every one of her suggestions!!!! Got more for our home than we thought we could and she made the transition and relocation to another state so much easier!!!! I've heard so many negative things about realtors and the moving process in general but McColly and Mrs. McColly have left an everlasting impression on us and will always play a role in any real estate ventures we, friends or family in Indiana I can recommend her for, she has definitely set a bar!!!!

Maria D. Santiago Thomsen, Dec 2016

...Customer Reviews

Friendly & Knowledgeable

I took the Realtor course a few years ago at the Valparaiso location, had a great teacher and learned a lot. Just recently bought our very first house using the Schererville Location and we used Wendy Embry as our realtor. She was a Great!! She was always very prompt to answer any questions or concerns, friendly, knowledgeable, and very professional. I would recommend her to Anyone! We also went through the Select Home Mortgage "Which is located inside of the Schererville McColly Office", Had a little bump in the middle due to the Loan officer leaving for another company but the loan officer from Valparaiso took over our case and finished promptly and on time. We overall were VERY satisfied. A wonderful first home buying experience. They all went above and beyond our expectations! We will use again if we decide to move in the future. :)

A Google User, 2011

...Customer Reviews


Our Realtor Melissa was amazing! She made us very comfortable at our first meet and was always available to answer any questions, as for being first time home buyers. Always quick to things and making sure we understood everything. Became a great friend and will always hold a place in our lives! We loved her, and the whole process!

Jessica R

...Customer Reviews

Professional & Patient

"I was thoroughly pleased with Taylor Bennett being my agent. She listens and accommodates to the best of her ability. She is professional, patient and very caring. My closing was very noisy and awkward. No introductions were made and most everything was done by the time I arrived. Nancy Best must be mentioned as she handled the confusion very professionally."

Wendy Rolph

...Customer Reviews


"Very patient, took as much time as we needed. Even helped us look for rentals. Thoughtful on how to sell our house. Spent some time shopping on our behalf to find accessories. Excellent support staff."

Angela Randall , Oct 2016

...Customer Reviews